Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  

New Rules of Golf Decision Limits Use of Video Review

Recommended Posts

This is a good change. What is a playing partner/marker for, if not to protect the rest of the field? These "TV Officials" need to be removed from the process.



Sent from my iPhone using MyGolfSpy

  • Like 1

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Now we're cooking with Crisco!



Sent from my iPhone using MyGolfSpy

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Honestly wish that they would have just said "No more calls/emails will be taken from the public regarding possible rules infractions". I just read a comment on another site asking: " what would happen if a viewer called in a possible infraction on a Monday, after the final round was completed?". I think that is a great question...there is still too much disparity with the new rule.

  • Like 2

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm interested by the reactions to this news.  Their decisions don't really outlaw video reviews, no matter whether its a viewer calling in, or someone in the network truck bringing it up, or an official taking a look to confirm something he thinks he sees.  It would (quite appropriately) eliminate penalties for things that aren't visible to the naked eye, like the Anna Nordquist grains of sand.  Ir would eliminate penalties if a player uses reasonable judgement in determine where to drop a ball.  However, it would NOT absolve Lexi, moving a ball 3/4 inch on a putting green isn't using reasonable judgement.The USGA/R&A are specifically NOT making any decisions on whether callers or emails would be ignored.  The are specifically NOT eliminating the 2-stroke penalty for signing an incorrect scorecard, when a player isn't aware that they've breached a rule.


This is a good change. What is a playing partner/marker for, if not to protect the rest of the field? These "TV Officials" need to be removed from the process.

The Fellow Competitor SHOULD protect the field, but fan favorite Phil Mickelson has said he's seen players moving the ball like Lexi did, and has apparently chosen NOT to protect the field.  Its a pack of buddies, they don't want to be responsible for enforcing penalties on other players.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • Daily Deals

  • Sponsors

  • Our Sponsors


  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
    • Most Online

    Newest Member
    Mac 59
  • Similar Content

    • By cksurfdude
      Happened across this very clever solution on Insta...
      Edit: Not a penalty anymore - *IF* the double-tap was unintentional... Thx, cnosil. (But you still have to be an adept trick shot artist - and s very good actor to pull it off!)
    • By Golfspy_CG2
      COVINGTON, Ga. – (December 28, 2018) - Bridgestone Golf, the #1 Ball-Fitter in Golf, announced today that in 2018 its TOUR Team achieved the most victories in one calendar year in company history.  In addition, Bridgestone Golf had more wins per Tour Team member than any other golf ball company. 
      Bridgestone’s hallmark Tour year totaled an incredible 8 PGA TOUR wins with just 4 staff players.  Of the 8 victories, 7 were won with Bridgestone’s acclaimed TOUR B X Golf ball.  The exceptional win for the TOUR B XS came in perhaps the most exciting and anticipated win of the season, marking Tiger Woods return to the winner’s circle at the season-ending TOUR Championship.    The final win of the year gave Bridgestone its 2nd season-ending championship, when Lexi Thompson relied on the TOUR B X in her triumph at the 2018 CME Group Tour Championship. 
      Bridgestone’s TOUR B X and TOUR B XS are designed for players with greater than 105 mph driver swing speeds. Both the X and XS were softened over their predecessors and provide more spin and greenside control due to their softer urethane cover formulation, while increased distance comes from enhanced aerodynamics and an improved 330 Dual Dimple design. The X is for those players looking for more power and ball speed off the tee, while the XS provides extra spin control and slightly softer feel greenside, while still maintaining low driver spin off the tee.
      Below is a rundown of the Bridgestone Tour Team’s wins and noteworthy achievements in 2018:
      ·       Winner of Waste Management Phoenix Open uses TOUR B X (Feb. 1-4, 2018)
      ·       Bryson DeChambeau wins The Memorial Tournament using TOUR B X (May 31- June 3, 2018)
      ·       Brandt Snedeker wins Wyndham Championship using TOUR B X while also shooting first career 59 in the opening round (Aug. 16-19, 2018)
      ·       Bryson DeChambeau wins THE NORTHERN TRUST using TOUR B X (Aug. 23-26, 2018)
      ·       Bryson DeChambeau goes back-to-back winning the Dell Technologies Championship with TOUR B X (Aug. 31-Sep. 3, 2018)
      ·       Tiger Woods Completes One of the Greatest Comebacks in Golf History winning the TOUR Championship with TOUR B XS (Sep. 20-23, 2018)
      ·       Bridgestone balls win 3 out of 4 FedEx Cup Playoff Events
      ·       Bryson DeChambeau wins Shriners for Hospitals for Children Open using TOUR B X (Nov. 1-4, 2018)
      ·       Matt Kuchar wins Mayakoba Golf Classic using TOUR B X (Nov. 8-11, 2018)
      ·       Lexi Thompson wins CME Group Tour Championship using TOUR B X (Nov. 15-18, 2018)
      “By any measure our Tour Team had a phenomenal year in 2018,” said Dan Murphy, Bridgestone Golf President & CEO. “At Bridgestone Golf our Tour Team strategy is one based on quality not quantity.  By achieving more wins per capita, per player, than any other company this year, we have demonstrated that our technology and performance is second to none and our stable of players is best-in-class in the game.”
      The TOUR B series balls that were used to achieve 9 total professional wins in 2018 are a result of Bridgestone’s continued commitment to providing premium tee-to-green performance to players of varying swing types. Bridgestone owns over 800 golf ball patents and fully leverages the company’s heritage of excellence in polymer science worldwide to design the industry’s most cutting-edge golf balls.
      For more information on the Bridgestone Golf Tour Team, the company’s entire offering of golf balls and help selecting the right ball for you, visit bridgestonegolf.com.
      About Bridgestone Golf
      Based in Covington, GA, Bridgestone Golf USA manufactures premium golf balls, clubs and accessories under the Bridgestone and Precept brands. The company started making golf balls in 1935 and today has more golf ball design patents than any other company. Beginning in 2006, Bridgestone revolutionized golf ball selection with its custom ball-fitting program, identifying a golfer’s ideal golf ball based on personal swing characteristics. Today, as the #1 Ball-Fitter in Golf, Bridgestone has conducted over 2.1 million fittings via a combination of live-fitting, online selection and its B-FIT App.  The consumer data gathered from ball-fitting continues to inspire Bridgestone’s innovative new golf ball designs, yielding industry-leading performance products for the entire range of players, from recreational golfers to the best in the world. Bridgestone Golf is proudly represented on international professional tours by icons such as Tiger Woods, Fred Couples, Matt Kuchar, Bryson DeChambeau and Lexi Thompson.  Bridgestone Golf USA is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Bridgestone Sports Co. Ltd., headquartered in Tokyo. More information:  bridgestonegolf.com.
    • By Golfspy_CG2
      I had not gotten around to watching this until today, and boy what a worthwhile watch.   Great discussion with Adam, Sam and Harry on the the 2018 Most Wanted Mallet Putter results, a really good look at how the test is conducted and a good review of each putter that finished in the Top 5.  
      Set 26 minutes aside, grab a beverage or two and enjoy.  Sounds like they may be doing similar vidoes on some of the other Most Wanted products as well. 
    • By Kansas King
      I am looking at buying a set of 2009 Callaway X-Forged or Razr X Forged. I played the 2007 X-Forged but since they were non-conforming, I switched to the Bridgestone J38 Dual Pocket Cavity (great clubs). I have the itch to go back to the Callaway forgings due to their weight (D2) (Bridgestone are a D1). Plus, I really like the look and feel of them.
      The Question:
      The 2009 X-Forged has grooves that are spaced "normal" but the Razr X Forged has the tightly spaced conforming grooves. Are the tighter grooves good or bad? (I've heard they don't change much) Additionally, does anyone know if the 2009 X-Forged (Version 2 on USGA Conforming Database) from Callaway have conforming grooves. The USGA database says additional testing required (ATR).
      If you have any input on how tighter grooves play it would be appreciated. I remember the conversations about it back in the day but I can't seem to find anything about it now.
      I'm a 5 handicap FYI.
    • By GolfSpy MPR
      Have you guys seen this?
      Quick summary:
      Web.com player in the hunt for a tournament win, hooks ball into hazard on the last hole. Caddie picks up ball. Rules official assesses a stroke penalty because the caddie got the ball without explicit authorization from the player. Gibson drops and hits, nearly holes out. Grabs putter out of the bag, pulls headcover, and flings the headcover at the caddie. Apparently at the same time, fires the caddie. Gibson finishes 3rd instead of T-2, costing him about $12,000. Caddie posts summary of the event on YouTube, including his argument that the penalty stroke should not have been assessed. My thoughts: first, events like this are always interesting to learn more obscure rules. It looks like the caddie is correct: there should not have been a penalty here. Provision is made in the decisions of golf for circumstances in which a drop is obvious that a caddie can pick the ball up without penalty.
      Second, Gibson comes out looking really bad. His anger is understandable, but any circumstance in which a person treats a subordinate (caddie, waitstaff, etc.) in a demeaning manner is a telling revelation of that person's character. Fire the guy: fine, that makes sense. But throwing things at him on the course? Childish and way over the line.
  • Recent Topics

  • Latest from the Blog

  • Happy Birthday Today!

  • Create New...