Looking at the new satin Cleveland TFI 2135's or the Huntington Beach #10's. Cleveland is doing some great stuff.
Might also take a look at picking up a year old Ketsch, based on previous most wanted performance. There's always the appeal of picking up an EVNROLL, however the $450+ pricetag is a bit tough to swallow.
Of course, with my seemore I had two good putting rounds last weekend (31 and 33 putts, very good for me), so maybe I won't be kicking it out of the bag just yet!
I completely agree with you on Cleveland's direction. I tried the Cleveland TFI 2135's when I was looking for my new putter. I just bought one about 2 weeks ago. Between the those two styles, I liked the TFI just a bit better. I felt like they made some improvements on the face and it just felt better. The thing that really stood out to me though was how easy it was to line up. I know that was the whole idea behind the 2135, but still have to prove it, right?
The putter I ended up going with was the Ping Oslo. I loved the face on it, and on mishits, I was still getting the same distance. I've never tested and Evnroll putter just because not many places in Indiana carry them, but I felt like the Ping was giving me the same promise that I've heard from Evnroll. If you go on 2nd swing they have great deals on a barely used one. I think it's around $200.
Something that I might suggest though first if you haven't tried it already is see if someone has your putter in a different lie. I'm actually getting my new one 1* flat. After putting with it that way, I just felt like my eyes were perfectly in line and it just freed up my stroke to what I wanted it to be.