Jump to content
GregB135

Florida League Course Reviews

Recommended Posts

Week 10: Innisbrook Resort, Island Course - Palm Harbor, FL

Tees Played:  Green: 6,686 yds 72.7/140 ; White: 6,130 yds 69.7/130

Conditions: Warm to Hot, Very Light Breeze

Price: $$$ ($75)

www.innisbrookgolfresort.com/golf/island-course

 

The Innisbrook Resort is a large golf and spa resort in Palm Harbor, just a short drive north of the Clearwater/St Petersburg area on the Central Florida gulf coast. A longtime favorite of Tampa Bay area golfers, the resort has three championship courses and hosts an annual PGA Tour event, now the Valspar Championship, on it's Copperhead course (previously reviewed). While not quite as long as Copperhead, the Island Course can play every bit as tough. The Island is somewhere between a shot-making and target golf course. Each hole offers a unique challenge creating a course that demands good decision making and shot choices, and then makes you execute those shots. 

 

The course conditions in general are very good to excellent. While Copperhead is the show-piece, the other courses are maintained with the same care and detail to ensure a quality golf experience for resort guests. The Island's fairways are narrow so accuracy off the tee is a premium for a good score. The turf conditions were excellent considering our summer date meant lots of recent rain. Even so, we were not cart path restricted and the fairways were only just soft enough to slightly affect roll. The rough was deep enough that you knew you didn't want to be in it, but it wasn't penalizing. Wander too far off the line of the hole there is a variety of trouble waiting for you. Some holes have bunkering around the landing area, others are lined with cypress, and others shaped by water (though maybe not as much as the name 'Island Course' suggests). The greens were in excellent condition, held shots well, and had true, consistent roll with medium speed that approached fast as they dried out from our early morning start. 

 

The practice facilities at all the resort's courses are very good. The Island's large practice putting/chipping green is adjacent to the clubhouse and first tee, and represents the course conditions well. The full swing range is across the street from the clubhouse but they maintain a 10 minute cycle of carts shuttling from the clubhouse to the range. The practice range has great turf, plenty of hitting stations and targets, quality practice balls, and coolers with chilled water bottles. Again, top rate even for a resort facility with a practice bunker the only piece lacking.

 

The best description for the course employees is fantastic. Clubhouse personnel were friendly, enthusiastic, helpful and informative. The outside assistants are a great source for info on how the course is set up and how it's playing. Since keeping things on-time is part of maintaining the good resort experience, you will see the on-course rangers more often than some other places. Our tournament play rules can slow things down a bit, but even with that we were only asked once to try and speed up our play. The rangers are present, but not typically fussy or in any way disrespectful. You'll also never find yourself wondering when/if you'll ever see the beverage cart again. They make rounds enough to avoid that without being intrusive or a hindrance. In short, I've never had a negative experience with any course employee during any of my several visits to the resort.

 

Overall impression: A definite recommend. Innisbrook does a fantastic job making sure you have an enjoyable golf experience. The Island course will challenge your course management and shot making skills while the course conditions and environment will leave you wanting to come back. Like most Florida resorts, the peak (cool weather) season rates will be a bit higher. You'll also want to be aware of the Tour's early spring play date as the resort accommodations will be full along with increased traffic and more crowded play at the other courses. 

 

 

 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

thanks for the reviews.enjoy reading them.

Even though I am at the opposite end of the country,it is nice to read about different courses.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Final Week: 2-Day - Mission Inn Resort, Howey In the Hills Florida

Tees Played: El Campeon - Blue 6,601 yds 73/139, White 6,242 yds 71.1/135

                     Las Colinas - Blue 6,829 yds 74.1/130, White 6,365 yds 71.3/129

Conditions: Hot, Humid, Afternoon Rain

Price: Golf $ ($49), Lodging $$$ 

https://missioninnresort.com

 

The Mission Inn Golf and Spa resort sits in little, out of the way, Howey In The Hills Florida. It is about a 45 minute drive from the eastern side of Orlando near Lake Harris and just east of the Florida Turnpike. This was our league's final regular event, played over two days. The first was on the El Campeon Course with the second round on the Las Colinas course. El Campeon is a challenging, shot-makers course with a parkland feel to the layout. Las Colinas has more of a links feel but still requires sound strategy and good shot making to manage a low score. Both courses offer more elevation change than you expect to find in Florida, and it is incorporated very well into the course designs. 

 

Course Conditions were consistent between the two courses, and between the better side of good and excellent. Tees were all well manicured. The fairways had good feel and playability and showed good drainage to maintain that after some heavy rain at the end of day one and overnight between rounds. Greens received shots well and rolled true with moderately fast speeds. The only mark against course conditions were some bare/rough spots along the edges of a few Las Colinas greens. Most of the greens are rather large and there is lots of undulation and slope that will challenge you to place the ball on the proper portion of the green with your approach or three putts are definitely in play. The rough on both tracks was noticeable but not penalizing, allowing you to miss the fairway - just don't miss by much. There are ample trees and other hazards that dictate the strategy for each hole such that any shot wandering too far off the line of play will likely cost you a stroke (or more) to get back in the hole.

 

The practice facilities are all adjacent to/near the central clubhouse. The large practice putting green sits across the path from the starting holes and replicates the on-course conditions well. There is a large, all turf, full-swing range and chipping/bunker practice area just across the parking lot with quality practice balls pre-positioned for each. The clubhouse attendants maintain a cart shuttle to-from the range or it is only a short walk. 

 

As expected with any resort property, the course employees were all friendly, energetic, and seemed genuinely interested in making sure we had a good experience. Clubhouse attendants were there with cart shuttle service from the parking lot and to the practice range. The were given our group's tee sheet, so carts were all pre-positioned. Post round club attendants were there to clean clubs, and were happy to hear stories of the round and share a laugh. There is also club storage available for guests of the resort. The folks inside the clubhouse were all fantastic as well. The bar/grill is fairly large and overlooks the 1st/18th fairways withe a view of the lake between. On-course personnel were present, without being intrusive. The rangers will be nice about asking you to maintain pace of play and the bev cart will circulate frequently enough you'll not need to wish for them.

 

Overall impression: the golf courses at Mission Inn will not disappoint and are worth the drive to play. They are challenging for all levels while being fun to play. Using good course strategy and making quality shots will lead to a good score, while wild misses or over-aggressive shot selection can quickly build up to big numbers. The golf courses are a great value and since this is a golf course review not a resort review I will only say the accommodations and other resort amenities may not feel like the same. A definite recommend for golf, while only a mild recommend for the overall resort. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Season 2/Week 1 - Crescent Oaks Country Club, Tarpon Springs FL

Tees Played: Black - 6,566 yds, 71.6/135; Blue - 5,951 yds, 68.7/123

Conditions: Sunny and Mild, light Breeze

Price: $ ($26.75)

http://www.crescentoaksgolf.com/

Course Description: Crescent Oaks Country Club is a public welcome golf facility within a gated community in Tarpon Springs FL, which is just north of Tampa Bay and a short drive from the Tampa/St Petersburg areas. The layout is a little bit of a mixed bag of shot-making parkland style, and links style holes. There are several short par 4's in the layout that offer ample scoring opportunities. The fairways tend to be narrow and there are some waste/deep rough areas to watch for as well as lots of water and bunkering that dictate shot choices and demand accuracy. The greens are relatively small and well protected and very few have any significant undulation. 

Course Conditions: The greens, though small did roll true with a consistently decent pace though I wouldn't call them fast. The fairways were firm and dry, and while green enough, the fairway lies tended to feel a little tight. The dry, shallow fairway conditions gave plenty of roll, though one of our league players who is a member said the course plays very soft and wet during the rainy summer months. The rough along the line of play was fair and deep enough to be noticeable without over-penalizing a minor miss. There are numerous fairway bunkers, deep rough areas, trees and other penalty areas (water) to contend with if your misses stray too far. Since it is a neighborhood course besides, there are quite a lot of out-of-bounds lines to deal with as well. The only real area to downgrade on the course was the tee boxes. They were very inconsistent with patchy turf and uneven ground on more teeing areas than were level and green.

Practice Facilities: Marginal. The full swing range is away from the clubhouse, and feels crowded even with only 7 or 8 stations. It is short and narrow as well. The range balls though were decent and there is a short game practice area with bunkers another short walk further than the range. The putting green was small and also felt crowded, though it did represent the course conditions well.

Course Employees: Considering this is a public course, and they were hosting three tournament groups on the day, I'll say I was impressed. The check in staff was friendly and helpful and did a great job of getting us out on the course and ready for play on time. The on-course ranger was present without being intrusive. We saw the beverage/snack cart only once during each 9, but the turn does bring you past the clubhouse. There is a small bar in the clubhouse as well as multiple banquet rooms, and all of the servers and other attendants were a pleasure to deal with.

Overall Impression: Crescent Oaks Country Club is a nice little, somewhat out-of-the-way course that presents a good value. It won't leave you wanting but don't expect to walk away overly impressed either. The course plays challenging and fair but doesn't have a true signature hole or anything that visually will make you say, 'Wow, what a great course to play'. We were one of three tournament groups they hosted on the day, and there was another clubhouse function happening during our post-round lunch, so it was a pretty crowded place later in the morning. All that said, for a tournament group, on a peak season Saturday morning hard to beat the price.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Great assessment of Crescent Oaks. As it is one of four courses owned and operated by Ace Golf, we take our Saturday group(40+ players) and play there at least once a year.


Sent from my iPad using MyGolfSpy

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
50 minutes ago, fozcycle said:

Great assessment of Crescent Oaks. As it is one of four courses owned and operated by Ace Golf, we take our Saturday group(40+ players) and play there at least once a year.


Sent from my iPad using MyGolfSpy

Thanks Foz,

As a fellow central Florida area golfer, I'll count on you to call me out on any blatant falsehood or heresy in these assessments. 😜

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

2019 Event #2 - Saddlebrook Resort, Palmer Course, Wesley Chapel Florida

Tees Played - A- Blue 6,273 yards / 72.5/136; B - White 5,820 yards / 69.5/133

Conditions - Hot, humid, moderate breeze

Price - $$ ($62)

https://www.saddlebrook.com/tampa-golf/

The Saddlebrook Resort has been a Tampa area mainstay for many years now, and is just a short drive north on I-75 from Tampa. It is a golf and tennis resort with a convention center. Two 18 hole courses are on the property, the Saddlebrook and Palmer courses, both designed by the second's namesake. After playing the Palmer Course, it is about shot making and strategy. Without much in the way of elevation change the layout steers shots with lots of doglegs, narrow fairways, and lots of water haz... penalty areas and bunkering. The greens are relatively small and have lots of undulation making distance control a factor. The course pretty much lives up to the billing given in the resort web site's description. Pretty much.

Course Conditions: In general very good without being spectacular. It is a resort course after all with everything from tee to green being reasonably well manicured. We did find a few spots of patchy rough, but those were rare, and in areas that wouldn't affect a majority of players. Tee areas were well groomed, level, and large enough to avoid degradation from excessive wear. The rough was distinct, but not deep along the line of play with lots of mounding that lets the challenge of the uneven lies make up for the shallower grass. Fairways played consistently well and had a really good feel as far as firmness and depth. The greens, the greens, the greens. The greens were good to very good on the side of general conditions, consistency of speed and roll and playability. They don't quite live up to the speed billing given by the web site. The TifEagle looks and plays great, but at the end of the day they are still bermuda greens. So even though they look smooth and fast, grain is a major factor, and bermuda just rolls slower than other types of grass, so the greens felt A LOT slower than they looked. Just about everyone in the group made some kind of remark about it after the round. They also didn't seem to hold shots like other greens with a little more bounce and roll rather than hit and stick on approach shots.

Practice Area/Range: This is the only real down side to the site. The practice area itself is very nice with lots of target flags, an ample full swing area, large chipping/putting green and practice bunkers. It is also home to the resort's golf school. So as a practice area I would rate it very good. As a pre-round warm-up option, not so much. The practice area is separate from the clubhouse. By separate I mean a cart journey of several minutes through houses and resort rentals. If you need a warm-up before the round, arrive early enough to give yourself lots, and I mean lots, of time to work it in. (There's more to that)

Course Employees/Customer Service: In general, everyone was pleasant to deal with and helpful and all of that. The check in was smooth and efficient and they managed to make it as easy as possible to keep our group where they wanted and needed to be to keep us on time without it feeling like we were being fussed at. From time of arrival through departure though, it felt very clear that most of the whole setup was geared toward serving resort guests and not daily play visitors. There is no self-parking, so you have to use the same valet service the resort guests use at resort reception. There isn't a dedicated bag drop, the reception crew loads you and your bag up on a cart and shuttles you to the pro shop area. The pro-shops for both tennis and golf are part of the central recreation area with the main resort pool and outdoor dining area. If I was staying there as a resort guest I would have called it great, as a visiting daily player it gave me the feeling I was a bit of an inconvenience. Again, the people were all very pleasant to deal with, but everything, and I mean everything but the golf was over-priced ($3.25 for a can of coke from the bev-cart, don't ask on the post-round beer).

Overall Impression: This one is a Recommend with an asterisk. The course was fun to play and was in great condition, even if not to the standard of some of its resort cousins in the area. That considered, the golf is worth it for the price, just know that anything extra is going to feel like it's overpriced. Without staying on-property overnight I can't offer an opinion of the resort at large, other than to say I might have left with a better impression of the overall experience had I been an overnight guest.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks GregB, there is s9me “employee” parking close to the pro shop, IF you know how to get there.


Sent from my iPad using MyGolfSpy

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Daily Deals

  • Sponsors

  • Our Sponsors

     
     
     

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      78,072
    • Most Online
      2,247

    Newest Member
    scott80109
    Joined
  • Similar Content

    • By GregB135
      Spent a couple of hours this afternoon at the Tampa Bay Golffest event. A really nice though not especially large demo day event hosted by Tampa Bay Downs. Had a chance to hit some of the new offerings out there in the marketplace and some potential GolfSpy test candidates. 
      Hit several drivers. The new Mizuno ST, Ping G410, Wilson Cortex, and Cobra F9 Speedback. Keeping in mind it wasn't full fitting for each, but the reps did ask enough questions to get you close enough spec wise so you were hitting something close to your current gamer. Of the 4, my least favorite was the Mizuno, it just didn't have the same feel as the others. The Ping G410 just felt AWESOME. The Cobra felt good, like the ball was exploding off the face, but the ball flight was a little higher than my preference, and the ball was airborne for.....ever. The Cortex was a surprise. Felt good and solid, sound and ball flight were right there with all the others. I hit a smattering of irons, but wasn't focused enough on those to include data. The latest of the Mizuno JPX forged though was a very solid feeling club. In any case, I didn't put anything back on the rack thinking "boy that sucked" so be encouraged GolfSpy universe, there is some really good equipment coming out this year.
      Also spied some of the new Bridgestone e12 golf balls in the sale tent. I'm sure we are all waiting for the revelation of those testers (my fingers are crossed).
      Last, I got some Trackman style feedback on the effectiveness of the SuperSpeed training system (about to start week 9 for me). Participating in the skills contests, included 4 Trackman assessed shots with driver. With a mis-fit glove, no warm-up, no golf shoes, and a random selection of not my drivers to choose from, I got all 4 swings onto the grid with 3 going past 270 at 100mph. About a 15-20 yard gain from last season!! Still waiting on the promised email with the Trackman video/data and pro comparison.
      A pretty cool afternoon.

    • By GregB135
      Hey fellow spies. Last summer I submitted course reviews from my competitive league season down here in the Tampa area. As I am preparing again for the start of the season in March, I will plan to do the course reviews again here, as well as summarizing my prep and performance. When the league schedule is posted I will list the courses, then as each play week concludes I'll do my course review and my best sports analyst impression to report on that week's play. I'll try to include a few more pictures this season as well, we play some pretty nice courses.
      The league has about 45 members, uses a full handicap stroke play format with each week's field set at 32-36 players split between two flights.. League points are earned for weekly placement, and there are options for skins and close-to-pin. There are three majors on the schedule worth double points, one of which is a two-day event, and another week set aside for a two-man team event. The season concludes a Top-20 invitational, then a Ryder Cup style event with teams selected by two team captains from first the top 20 finishers, then captains picks from the rest of the field.
      Since I finished 25th last year, my goal for the season is to crack the Top-20 and earn a playing spot in the invitational and an invite to the Cup event.
      What have I done to prepare so far? Lessons for one thing, though I'm not certain the teacher/student dynamic is working well because I sometimes struggle to translate his input into something I can feel in my swing. I was lucky enough to be selected for the Odyssey EXO putter test, and my putting has been improving since. Since I'm now one year away from Champions Tour eligibility, I got a set of the SuperSpeed Training system to at least try to maintain what club speed I've got left, if not improve a bit. 
      I hope you all enjoy reading about the journey, and I welcome any/all input and encouragement.
      Cheers for now.
    • By Golfspy_CG2
      After some discussion in a couple different threads there appears to be a simmering interest in having a MGS Golf Outing somewhere this spring.  So taking what little has been discussed already and putting it in one place for  a proposed outing this Spring.
       
      Where: World Woods Golf Course, Brooksvillle Florida (about 45 minutes north of Tampa Intl Airport)    http://www.worldwoods.com/
       
       
      When: Late March to Late  April   (March 31/April 2 or April 7/9 or April 21/23
       
      Who: Any Interested MGS'er and Guests
       
       
      So we know we have a least a couple long time MGS'ers in the area in Rev and Foz, and a couple new ones I believe as well.  The courses are ranked in the Top 100 you can play on many golf lists.  
       
      Tampa is about as easy and affordable of airport as you can find to fly into.   
       
      I've done a bit of searching on the course and the associated villas and the rates on golf go down significantly after April 1 and I'm thinking flights do as well.   I know Rev has mentioned the 2nd week or so of April would leave him out, so that might make the Weekend of April 7/8.  That is The Masters weekend, for better or worst, just so everyone knows.   The following weekend is Easter weekend, so that is definitely a no go.     The third weekend mentioned would be the latest I could go, as it starts to get into our busy outing season after that. 
       
      I'm going to see if I can attach a poll to the thread, and feel free to vote and make any general comments or suggestions in the thread.  After we get some responses, we'll start seeing if it's realistically doable and narrow things down. 
    • By Aotearoa_Brad
      There's a really good blog post digging into golfer performance by handicap level this morning, which utilizes TheGrint's database of recorded rounds. One of the other features of TheGrint is the ability for everyday golfers, like you and me, to give a brief overview of the condition and playability of the courses that you visit.
       
      I've been a 'Grinter' for the last year and have found it really useful - I've even played a round with a random person through TheGrint and the local Club that I'm a part of.
       
      TheGrint have come up with the Top-20 courses in the US. I know, everybody has their own list of Top-20 courses - this list is compiled from over 100,000 reviews on its site from members who have played the courses. The list is limited to courses that have had at least 30 reviews, but gives both a 'fun rating' and 'shape rating'. There are some well known courses on here, but most I've not heard of (no local courses in Hawaii make the list, unfortunately).
       

      http://www.thegrint.com/range/2014/11/thegrint-top-20-golf-courses-ranking-grinters/
       
      The link has photos of all of the Top-20 courses as well - some of which look amazing!
       
      Have you played any of these courses? Would you agree with the rankings for the ones you've played? Are there any surprizes in your neck of the woods?
  • Recent Topics

  • Latest from the Blog

  • Happy Birthday Today!

×
×
  • Create New...