Jump to content
2 Weeks Remaining: MODERATOR WANTED Join the MyGolfSpy Staff! Read more... ×
mpatrickriley

Indoor putting green surfaces | UPDATE: review and crazy good sale!

Recommended Posts

Making progress. Taking lots of care to cut the holes as perfect as I can. Should have everything together this week, and I'll get the review done.

At this point, I'll say this: this is exactly what I was hoping it would be. I'll mention some quibbles, but I'm pleased with my purchase.

IMG_20181014_202534.jpeg

  • Like 6

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Looks amazing so far, keep us updated and if you have time maybe a layout of how you built the whole thing?

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
13 hours ago, GolfSpy Meyer said:

Looks amazing so far, keep us updated and if you have time maybe a layout of how you built the whole thing?

Some of the information about the build is found in one of my first posts here: 

 

The basic structure is just 2x4s with a plywood surface. I wanted to do it this way in order to allow the use of real holes. The green is 6"x11", and the support beams run width-wise. Here's a picture of the frame.

20171111_112100.jpg

If you look very closely at the center of the support beams, each us partially cut in the middle, and then reinforced with a wooden bracket. What this allowed us to do is intentionally bow the support beams, so that half the green would be as flat as possible, and the other would be tilted slightly. The other brilliant idea my dad had was to screw lag bolts in under the frame every few feet. This allowed us to make subtle adjustments to how the whole frame sits on the floor.

After the frame was built and the plywood screwed down, we put down a layer of those interlocking foam tiles, and then the putting surface (which, as I mentioned, was a kind of mid-range heavy felt). I'm currently putting the new surface on top of all of this.

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Four of the five holes are cut. I have one more hole in the center, but this time around, I'm making a plug for it. I put it there initially to allow for a clock drill, but there simply isn't room on the green to make it profitable, and having the hole in the middle got in the way of so many other putts.

The holes are really close to final. All of them are just a tiny bit smaller than 4.25". Obviously, erring on the small side is best, both because they can be fixed, and if I don't fix them, it's just better practice.

Using the rotary tool for finishing the holes is perfect. The blade cuts through just fine, and it's spinning fast enough that it melts some of the edge grass together.

The next step is marking the green with the dots I use for practice.

IMG_20181016_210838.jpeg

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Four of the five holes are cut. I have one more hole in the center, but this time around, I'm making a plug for it. I put it there initially to allow for a clock drill, but there simply isn't room on the green to make it profitable, and having the hole in the middle got in the way of so many other putts.

The holes are really close to final. All of them are just a tiny bit smaller than 4.25". Obviously, erring on the small side is best, both because they can be fixed, and if I don't fix them, it's just better practice.

Using the rotary tool for finishing the holes is perfect. The blade cuts through just fine, and it's spinning fast enough that it melts some of the edge grass together.

The next step is marking the green with the dots I use for practice.

IMG_20181016_210838.thumb.jpeg.78026dbd7051173439962624f92a48e3.jpeg
you're quite the handiman.
the problem with that is the wife knows your capabilities



Sent from my SM-G900W8 using MyGolfSpy mobile app

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, Har in the Hat said:

you're quite the handiman.
the problem with that is the wife knows your capabilities

emoji2.png emoji2.png

Sent from my SM-G900W8 using MyGolfSpy mobile app
 

In all honesty, I'm a tremendously incompetent handyman. I'm willing to tackle a project like this chiefly because it is relatively trivial: if I get it wrong, no one gets electrocuted, the plumbing still works, the cars still function. Projects that are actually important get farmed out to people who know what they're doing, like my dad—who is responsible for having built the frame for the green itself :)

  • Like 6

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My goal was to find a high quality, mid-price putting surface. There are lots of bargain surfaces, most of which are a kind of heavy felt. And we know there are a variety of higher-end products, like Birdie Ball and Big Moss, but that these often carry a hefty price tag, especially if you build a green of significant size. My green is 6x11, and so a Birdie Ball surface would run me around $300.

Scouring the internet, I found this site: https://megagrass.com/collections/golf-courses-and-putting-greens. I exchanged some emails with their customer service, asking questions about the difference between their turf levels. They responded very quickly and helpfully.

I also found that they sell their highest end green surface at precut sizes on Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B07BX5KLHN/

The price on Amazon is substantially lower than what they list on their website. PLEASE NOTICE THIS: they are having a sale right now (Oct 18, 2018, 10:00am CDT). Go click that link, click the 10% off coupon, order the 8x10 green for $78! Then come back and finish reading this review. Seriously: go order it now. That's $40 less than what I paid, and I thought I got a good deal.

The turf itself is light years better than the cheap felt surface. Here are some pictures to give you a sense of its texture:

IMG_20181018_082444.jpg

IMG_20181018_082453.jpg

IMG_20181018_082501.jpg

It is a grass surface, not a mat. It is designed to be used either indoor or out, with proper drainage.

As for speed: I noted that my green has an uphill/downhill setup. I used my Putt Out as a budget Stimpmeter. On felt, a putt released from the "18-inches-past-the-hole" point rolled out nearly six feet downhill, and uphill about two feet. That's Augusta-fast.

On the MegaGrass surface, it rolled out 30" downhill, and about 15" uphill. This is much closer to the speed of ordinary greens that I suspect most of us play on. I am very, very pleased with the speed.

The surface trims well. The straight cuts are very easy with an ordinary utility knife. For the holes, I rough cut them with a utility blade, and then gradually increased the size with a rotary tool. This had the advantage of also melting the grass fibers a bit, to make a cleaner edge of the cup:

IMG_20181018_082609.jpg

I've mentioned earlier in this thread that I have some quibbles. The first would be that there was a section of the green that came with about a 24" wrinkle. The other is that there is a line in the green in which I'm guessing the grass is thicker than in other places, almost like one line of grass was doubled in production. These are obviously problems when you're looking for a smooth putting surface.

My understanding is that the wrinkles can be fixed by leaving the green out in the sun, but that wasn't a real option for me. Fortunately, because my green is smaller than 8x10, I was able to simply cut off the wrinkled portion.

The other line is slowly being worked into submission, through a combination of combing and pressing.

All told, guys, I would have a hard time believing that you can get a better surface at this price point, especially at the price you can get them at the time I'm writing. If you've been looking for a practice surface (winter is coming!), I don't think you'll go wrong here.

If you've got any other questions, I'd be happy to answer them.

  • Like 6

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How to you think it would work just being rolled out onto a carpeted surface?

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 minutes ago, MattF said:

How to you think it would work just being rolled out onto a carpeted surface?

Really good question, and not a terribly easy one to answer. I initially unrolled it on the concrete floor of my garage, and noticed that when someone walked on it, it would move around. This isn't something I would have expected of an 8x10 carpet, but the combination of the thick stiffness of the grass fibers (which when stepped on would want to transfer energy to the backing) and the relatively hard plastic backing meant that it really didn't stay still on the concrete when walked on.

On carpet, it has a better chance of laying still.

Now, whether it would lay flat depends in part on the carpet underneath. If you unrolled it on a tight carpet, I suspect it would be just awesome. That's more or less what I've got, since mine is laying on top of the felt layer.

My guess is that if you're thinking about just a putting strip (something like a 3x10), it should lay well and functionally on any surface. The only issue you'd have to deal with is that if you're standing on the ground next to the grass, you will be almost 3/4" below the grass level, which isn't ideal for putting.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 10/18/2018 at 10:54 AM, mpatrickriley said:

My goal was to find a high quality, mid-price putting surface. There are lots of bargain surfaces, most of which are a kind of heavy felt. And we know there are a variety of higher-end products, like Birdie Ball and Big Moss, but that these often carry a hefty price tag, especially if you build a green of significant size. My green is 6x11, and so a Birdie Ball surface would run me around $300.

Scouring the internet, I found this site: https://megagrass.com/collections/golf-courses-and-putting-greens. I exchanged some emails with their customer service, asking questions about the difference between their turf levels. They responded very quickly and helpfully.

I also found that they sell their highest end green surface at precut sizes on Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B07BX5KLHN/

The price on Amazon is substantially lower than what they list on their website. PLEASE NOTICE THIS: they are having a sale right now (Oct 18, 2018, 10:00am CDT). Go click that link, click the 10% off coupon, order the 8x10 green for $78! Then come back and finish reading this review. Seriously: go order it now. That's $40 less than what I paid, and I thought I got a good deal.

The turf itself is light years better than the cheap felt surface. Here are some pictures to give you a sense of its texture:

IMG_20181018_082444.jpg

IMG_20181018_082453.jpg

IMG_20181018_082501.jpg

It is a grass surface, not a mat. It is designed to be used either indoor or out, with proper drainage.

As for speed: I noted that my green has an uphill/downhill setup. I used my Putt Out as a budget Stimpmeter. On felt, a putt released from the "18-inches-past-the-hole" point rolled out nearly six feet downhill, and uphill about two feet. That's Augusta-fast.

On the MegaGrass surface, it rolled out 30" downhill, and about 15" uphill. This is much closer to the speed of ordinary greens that I suspect most of us play on. I am very, very pleased with the speed.

The surface trims well. The straight cuts are very easy with an ordinary utility knife. For the holes, I rough cut them with a utility blade, and then gradually increased the size with a rotary tool. This had the advantage of also melting the grass fibers a bit, to make a cleaner edge of the cup:

IMG_20181018_082609.jpg

I've mentioned earlier in this thread that I have some quibbles. The first would be that there was a section of the green that came with about a 24" wrinkle. The other is that there is a line in the green in which I'm guessing the grass is thicker than in other places, almost like one line of grass was doubled in production. These are obviously problems when you're looking for a smooth putting surface.

My understanding is that the wrinkles can be fixed by leaving the green out in the sun, but that wasn't a real option for me. Fortunately, because my green is smaller than 8x10, I was able to simply cut off the wrinkled portion.

The other line is slowly being worked into submission, through a combination of combing and pressing.

All told, guys, I would have a hard time believing that you can get a better surface at this price point, especially at the price you can get them at the time I'm writing. If you've been looking for a practice surface (winter is coming!), I don't think you'll go wrong here.

If you've got any other questions, I'd be happy to answer them.

Looks great and thanks for the review! I really like the cauterized look of the grass around the hole, can you show us how you used the rotary tool do that?

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
12 minutes ago, Headhammer said:

Looks great and thanks for the review! I really like the cauterized look of the grass around the hole, can you show us how you used the rotary tool do that?

I'm just using the basic cutting wheel that you get a dozen of in any collection of rotary attachments:

FFI4UHWGV9SPH85.LARGE.jpg

Because the holes were already in place on my green before I got this surface, I had to make sure I cut the surface holes in exactly the right place. And the problem with measuring is that there weren't a lot of good options to measure from.

So I've ended up gradually cutting the holes, slowly expanding them from the inside, mostly eyeballing them to the holes. Since the holes are already cut, I work the rotary tool from below the putting surface, cutting upward. As I cut upward, moving deliberately, the plastic blades of grass tend to fuse together to create those edges. Cutting downward, turf-then-backing, doesn't create the same result, in my experience.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      75,428
    • Most Online
      2,247

    Newest Member
    ChrisGio
    Joined
  • Exo Putters   7 members have voted

    1. 1. Which Model of the EXO Putters would YOU play?


      • Seven
      • Rossie
      • Indianapolis

    Please sign in or register to vote in this poll. View topic
  • HAPPY BIRTHDAY!!

    • Peaksy68

      Peaksy68 1,976

      Members
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • lastoka

      lastoka 6

      Members
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • sai-jin

      sai-jin 1

      Members
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • mitcheldo@att.net

      mitcheldo@att.net 0

      Members
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • drb1956

      drb1956 0

      Members
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • jennywhite

      jennywhite 0

      Members
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Wejlax

      Wejlax 0

      Members
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Yvesgo

      Yvesgo 0

      Members
      Joined:
      Last active:
  • Popular Contributors

  • Recent Status Updates

    • warbirdlover

      Older then dirt
      · 0 replies
    • Jaredchadd

      Where do i fill out "what's in my bag"?
      · 1 reply
    • Mitchdpg

      Avid 3-4 handicap golfer, product tester, always tinkering and trying to get better. 
       
      · 0 replies
    • MWGolf23

      Next steps to my road to improvement
      Current
       Adding the Mizuno MMC FliHi 4 iron to the bag once it comes it to replace my hybrid. The hybrid has too significant of a draw bias, not terrible, but I also draw the ball naturally already, and will probably go in and out of the bag, but I'm looking for better shot shaping with the FliHi and have that 210 to 225 distance into the green and off of the tee. Working on my putting. I'm rolling the ball nicely now with a slightly open stance with my current putter. I have another putter that I can get the ball rolling online, but the pace is off. Future step is to actually get fit for a putter. Working on my natural tempo and swing speed for the driver to have more consistent drives. See below for more info. Next
      Driver shaft optimization. Not looking for a new head yet. I like my 2017 M1 460. Interested in the journey of testing some shafts. Right now my shaft is determining what kind of shot I can do. Slower speed and tempo than my natural speed and tempo. This has lead to a great deal of inconsistency of trying to find the "magic speed and tempo" and I know that isn't the way to go. Swing speed training. I'll have multiple shafts at this point so I can game whatever is best fitting me as I go along. And I can always swing a little slower or club down to hit a fairway. Future
      Get fitted for a putter > get fitted for a driver/shaft and woods from a high level, reputable company willing to discuss numbers and takes the time and right approach. Open to custom shafts and not just from the OEM cart like at a Golf Galaxy. I have only been fitted to a driver once, but didn't purchase as I did not like the experience, small selection of shafts, and I wasn't swinging my natural speed and tempo like I should have.  
       
      · 0 replies
    • WestlakeGolf

      I'm really liking the new UI on this forum. It looks really clean!
       
      · 0 replies
×