Jump to content
Golfspy_CG2

2019 Official Forum Member Review- Tommy Armour TA3 Impact Putter

Recommended Posts

Thank you to each of the testers for taking on the task of providing your experiences with the Impact No. 3.  We are glad to see the thoroughness of the stage 1 introductions, and we are very excited to see your stage 2 posts.  Looking forward to following along, and contributing to the discussion!

-Tommy Armour Golf Team

  • Like 9

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Great stage 1 guys. A few months ago I went to our local DSG to try a TA3, and found it to be a nice putter!  I hope you do as well.  But one thing stuck out to me, that was when I would address the ball, the putter face looked open to me.  I thought I noticed that in some of your top down photos addressing the golf ball.  Are you guys seeing this as well?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
39 minutes ago, JohnSmalls said:

Great stage 1 guys. A few months ago I went to our local DSG to try a TA3, and found it to be a nice putter!  I hope you do as well.  But one thing stuck out to me, that was when I would address the ball, the putter face looked open to me.  I thought I noticed that in some of your top down photos addressing the golf ball.  Are you guys seeing this as well?

Actually, I find the opposite to be true.  The TA3 feels closed at address compared to my gamer.  What's worse is that the TA3 feeling closed scared me a little; I have a tendency to miss short putts to the left if I get too nervous and squeeze the grip too tight.  I'm happy to say that at least in my initial testing, this hasn't been an issue.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
29 minutes ago, skrupa15 said:

Actually, I find the opposite to be true.  The TA3 feels closed at address compared to my gamer.  What's worse is that the TA3 feeling closed scared me a little; I have a tendency to miss short putts to the left if I get too nervous and squeeze the grip too tight.  I'm happy to say that at least in my initial testing, this hasn't been an issue.

Interesting.  My misses tend to be pushes, and I was worried that the TA3 would really highlight that since it looked open to me.  Once I started rolling the ball at the store, my concerns quickly disappeared and I put it on the intended line with little problem.  Maybe these things are magic?

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Had another go with this putter on Sunday... Interesting results. 

I am having a difficult time with the look down behind the ball. We will see how this stacks up over the next few weeks.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'll have to definitely check this out at my local golf  store..

Edited because I have fat fingers and typed some weird stuff...lol

MDGolfHacker

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Great stage 1 guys. A few months ago I went to our local DSG to try a TA3, and found it to be a nice putter!  I hope you do as well.  But one thing stuck out to me, that was when I would address the ball, the putter face looked open to me.  I thought I noticed that in some of your top down photos addressing the golf ball.  Are you guys seeing this as well?
You arent the first person to say that which is really interesting. I personally feel it has a very square position behind the ball. I have adjusted my swing path by straightening it out a bit which has been keeping it straighter.

Sent from my SM-G950U using MyGolfSpy mobile app

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have taken the TA3 on the road for testing.  Last week I tested it on several of the courses in Hot Springs Village.  This week I took it to The Territory in Oklahoma.  Stay tuned for the results!

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Had my first disappointing putting round today since getting the TA3. Now by the numbers it was an average round for me but it was slightly worse then the previous 2 I had with the TA3. Had some real difficulty controlling speed on mid range putts, either buzzed edges or put it 5-10 feet past.

Sent from my SM-G950U using MyGolfSpy mobile app

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just played the other day and had 28 total putts. 8 one putts and 3 birdie. If I had struck the ball better this could have been a sub 80 round easy.


Sent from my iPhone using MyGolfSpy

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

One of the things I love about this review is how many different types of original gamers we have for a comparison!  With that being said, do you guys feel that the ball is rolling better off the face compared to your current gamers?  That's one of the first things I always look at with putters is how much the ball is skipping, especially on longer putts.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
One of the things I love about this review is how many different types of original gamers we have for a comparison!  With that being said, do you guys feel that the ball is rolling better off the face compared to your current gamers?  That's one of the first things I always look at with putters is how much the ball is skipping, especially on longer putts.
I feel the ball rolls very well, surprisingly better then my Odyssey #7. What I am most impressed with is the roll I get even on poor strikes. I cannot remember a skip I've had within 15 ft. On longer putts I'll get the occasional skip but one that's my buggaboo range and two it's mostly caused by my poor tempo and nothing to do with the TA3.

Sent from my SM-G950U using MyGolfSpy mobile app

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
One of the things I love about this review is how many different types of original gamers we have for a comparison!  With that being said, do you guys feel that the ball is rolling better off the face compared to your current gamers?  That's one of the first things I always look at with putters is how much the ball is skipping, especially on longer putts.

Been switching back and forth between the gamer and the TA3 noticing that the TA3 feels like it comes off the face more on line than my current gamer. On longer putts I have not been able to tell too much of a difference as of yet.

Another weird thing, due to the smallness of the TA3 putter face I find that I am hitting the center of my MLA much more often than before, weird tidbit but I think the TA3 is helping the ball striking in my putting.


Sent from my iPhone using MyGolfSpy
  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ok whoever started the open club face talk has gotten in my head because I am having an awful time closing the club face and sending putts left. Had a horrid day putting with 5 3-putts, the positive is the shortest 3-putt was 30 ft the longest 82. Looks like I need to work on proximity to the hole.

Sent from my SM-G950U using MyGolfSpy mobile app

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, HeathS16 said:

Another weird thing, due to the smallness of the TA3 putter face I find that I am hitting the center of my MLA much more often than before, weird tidbit but I think the TA3 is helping the ball striking in my putting. emoji28.png

I don't think there's anything weird about that it all. It's like those tiny holes on the practice green that make you really focus, so when you putt into a normal sized cup, it looks huge and you feel like you can't miss it.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Which type of putting stroke do you guys suggest the TA3 is best suited for?

Straight back and straight through. Though a small arch does at times feel a bit more comfortable and sends the ball well.


Sent from my iPhone using MyGolfSpy
  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Straight back and straight through. Though a small arch does at times feel a bit more comfortable and sends the ball well.


Sent from my iPhone using MyGolfSpy
100% straight back straight through. I putt with a slight arc and find myself occasionally getting into trouble with that. The straighter I am the better.

Sent from my SM-G950U using MyGolfSpy mobile app

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)
On 7/13/2019 at 2:27 AM, tchat07 said:

100% straight back straight through. I putt with a slight arc and find myself occasionally getting into trouble with that. The straighter I am the better.

Sent from my SM-G950U using MyGolfSpy mobile app
 

Yes, I would agree, been trying to play around with different strokes and find SBST to be the most consistent. I tend to pull more putts when I use a bit more arc. 

Edited by HeathS16
  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Yes, I would agree, been trying to play around with different strokes and find SBST to be the most consistent. I tend to pull more putts when I use a bit more arc. 
Agreed lots of balls ending up a little more left then I planned. My problem is maintaining SBST on longer putts, I tend to add some arc toward the back end which leads to a pull and often poor distance control.

Sent from my SM-G950U using MyGolfSpy mobile app

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Daily Deals

  • Sponsors

  • Our Sponsors

     
     
     

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      81,967
    • Most Online
      2,247

    Newest Member
    Burt_Macklin
    Joined
  • Similar Content

    • By Golfspy_CG2
      Ever since Evnroll putters came on the scene a couple years ago as the surprising winner of the My Golf Spy Most Wanted putter, it's been on a roll ever since.   The latest model it's ER2B has a high standard to live up to, and we have selected four members to test, review and report their results back to the forum.  That begins this week as you can check in with them over the next four to six weeks to see how they are performing.

       
      The Testers are
      @ncwoz                  Stage 1                          Stage 2
      @Wedgie                Stage 1                          Stage 2
      @Tsmithjr9             Stage 1                          Stage 2
      @KurtActual          Stage 1                           Stage 2
       
    • By ChasingScratch
      Perfect Practice Putting Mat Review
      By Chasing Scratch
       
      If you’re like me, you need to practice your putting……. A lot…… I mean take the time you want to practice each month, multiply it by 10, then add 10 hours to that.  Let’s face it, of all the skills in the game of golf, putting is something many of us amateurs tend to practice the least.  When was the last time you heard people at the course talking ‘bout “Man I spent 5 hours last week on my putting, and I just can’t get enough!”  The putter is hit more times in a single round than any other club yet we have this avoidance affair with it.  We’ll smash driver for hours on the range, look at the watch, and give 5 minutes to putting.

      I’m guilty of this myself.  As someone who knows I need to practice my putting more, it’s just not that much fun.  It’s also not very convenient for me.  The closest course to my home is 25 minutes away.  50 minutes in the car is a large commitment for me just to practice putting several days per week.

      So given my goal of scratch golf, my knowledge of statistics, and my passion for improvement, I started looking into “at home” putting training aids.  I searched around on the internet for everything from putting mats, auto-return systems, and DIY putting platform building guides. 

      I liked a few of the products just fine and was narrowing down my options to a few of the mats.  I know several had great reviews and even skill-type-games you can play, but I just couldn’t get over not having the ball fall into a cup.  There is something satisfying about seeing the golf ball fall into a hole and disappear.  So I started to plan out a putting platform build.  I had the specs and was all set to go to the store and spend a few days knocking it out.

      Literally the night before I was going to go to the store, I stumbled upon a page on Instagram called “Perfect Practice Golf” and saw their putting mat.  They had a giveaway contest going on for the PGA Championship so I threw my name in for the drawing.  I decided to wait and see if I got lucky before I built my platform and (wouldn’t you know it!)  I won!  So I decided to hold off on building a platform to see if this thing was any good.

      Their Instagram page showed quite a few PGA Tour players (e.g., Tony Finau, Marc Leishman, Smiley Kaufman, see their quotes below) who were using their putting mat so I figured it would be good enough for me.


      Quality and features

      When it arrived, the first thing I noticed was that the actual putting carpet was top notch.  I’m sure you’ve all seen the putting mats you can buy at the big box stores and the carpet they come with looks like something that is made out of cardboard.  You have to lay encyclopedias on it and even then you may have some creases, it never lays flat, etc.  Straight out of the box, this thing unrolled and lay flat.  You could literally start putting on it right out the box!

      The actual material feels a lot like velour (that's the best way I can describe it although it is not a perfect description).  They call it “crystal velvet,” but all I know is it is a very pure rolling surface.  A plus is that you can vacuum it as well.

      On that mat, you’ll find printed markings for every foot and smaller marks for every inch (it looks like a giant ruler).  You also have two alignment lines (one for the regular sized hole and one for the mini-hole).  As a golfer who struggles with “seeing the line” over my putts, the alignment line really helps.


      The mat also features an incline up to the holes, to ensure a confident stroke and to assist with the gravity-fed ball return system.  On their first version, the base and return ramp were made out of plastic.  It had a good weight to it and I had no complaints.  On their newest model, they made some upgrades to the base material.  Namely, it is now made of wood instead of plastic, there is an insert-able backstop to catch putts hit with too much gusto, extra space behind the holes to catch balls, and the return ramp has magnets to connect the pieces.  Each of these upgrade adds much more “high quality” feel to the overall product.  They did not change the crystal velvet putting surface, and in my opinion they didn’t need to.  It’s great as is.


      With the original version, my kids had a tendency to hit the ball past the holes and off the mat.  They were more than happy to chase the balls down the hallway, but it was a bit of an oversight in the original design.  This has been fixed in the newest version.  It would take a freaking missile launch of a putt to blast it off the mat now.

      For the price, I’d be hard pressed to find a better putting training aid.  At just over $100, you get a high quality putting surface and the mental boost of seeing a ball fall into a hole over and over and over again.  You can roll it up, stick it under your bed, and putt every single day, rain or shine, all from the comfort of your home. 

      This thing rolls fast and true.  They claim it rolls up to a 14 on the stimp if you put it on hard floors (think wood floors or concrete), and you can slow it down by putting it on carpet.  When I put it on my bedroom carpet, it is noticeably slower than when it is on the tile floor.

      If I were to have a critique, it would be that I wish the mat were just about a 1/4 inch thicker.  I have tile floor in my home and carpet in the bed rooms.  When putting on the tile floor, you can get a bump here or there (due to the gaps in the tiles and grout).  I fixed this by using some runner rugs we have in the hallway and I typically just put them under the mat.  I can’t be too critical, because I know that adding more thickness would increase the price, add to shipping, etc.  Overall it is a solid putting mat well worth the price.  I have hit hundreds of putts on the original model and the newest model and have yet to notice any depressions or grooves in the surface.  I know this is a concern for any putting mat, but so far so good on this one.

      Performance on the course

      For the first few weeks that I had the original Perfect Practice Golf putting mat, I couldn’t get enough of it.  My kids and I would spend hours throughout the day hitting 4 footers, 6 footers, 8 footers, etc.  We even came up with a trick shot and had a blast doing it (see video below)! 
       
      [/url]  
      My son and I came up with other putting games to play on it to keep it fun.  My on the course putting showed definite improvement as well!  I rarely had less than 35 putts per round before and quite often a few three putts.  When I was putting consistently with the Perfect Practice mat, I didn’t have a round over 32 putts.  Those pesky 6-7 foot par save putts were falling with much more consistency.  I felt like I had a real chance to hole everything inside of 10 feet.  Seeing the ball fall into a hole over and over and over while practicing at home is such a mental boost for my game.
      I haven’t played golf in over a month, much less practiced on my mat (life just got very very crazy in the Chasing Scratch home).  I want to make myself a personal goal of hitting 50 putts per day to see how good I can get.  Since I have a solid mat in the comfort of my own home, there really is no excuse.  If I want to get to scratch golf, I need to get those putts per round down to 30 or under consistently.  The only way to get better is to practice.  I’ve got a great practice aid to do it, now I just need the determination and dedication.
      At $130, I don’t think you can go wrong with this training aid.  The upgrades are a nice improvement over the original version, and the putting surface is top notch.  Take a look at their webpage (click here) and consider the Perfect Practice Golf mat if you are in the market for a putting setup for the home, office, or wherever really.  They sell out quickly when they get their shipments in, so they are on pre-order right now.
      I hope you enjoyed this review!  Now I’m off to go work on my putting!

      [/url](Note:  The images used in this review are used with permission from the company's website)
      [/url][/url]  
    • By downlowkey
      Form Forged Cleveland TA3
      3-PW - Raw Finish - Debadged
      True Temper Tour Concept X1
      Golf Pride New Decade Multi Compound
      Clean Heads - Custom Paint Fill (see pics)
      7-iron 37.5”
      Mild shaft finish wear 6, 9, PW (worst is pictured)
      This is a very rare setup - Tour Van Build
      $400 shipped to US (lower 48) - PayPal






    • By Davis Moes
      I'm getting rid of my seemore pure center blade putter I've owned for 2 years (purchased summer 2017). I am asking $120 OBO including shipping. If I don't have a lot of interest it will go on eBay. 
      Putter is in near mint condition. See actual photos of the putter below. Has additional weighting in the head as well as counterbalancing in the grip, length is 34.5".
      Paypal is my preferred payment method.
      Directly below is a list of the complete specs on the putter when I ordered it. Thanks for looking!

       


       




    • By FromRightToLeft
      Hello all! Thought I would chime in on this putter since I've owned it for a few months now.
       
       
      I had been using a Ping Ketch mallet putter since the beginning of the year. (I am relearning the game left handed this year due to a back issue and decided to do so with the putter as well) I had been putting fairly well with it but found it a bit hard to line up and I didn't love it, like all putters I have owned. I saw the testing and reviews on this putter and decided to buy it online sight unseen.
       
      I tend to like a longer putter and got it in the 35” model.
       
      (Aside: A member of the forum let me know that it could be bought here in Canada on golfworks.ca as we don't have Dick's here, so thank you whoever you were. It was $130 Canadian. It arrived super well packed, maybe better than any other golf club I've ever gotten in the mail. There were two small scratches on the putter shaft. I decided to email golfworks and see what they had to say about it. The service was incredible and the best I've ever had online. They got back to me within an hour with an apology and said they would ship out a new one that day and they had a shipping label for me to return mine with. For me the scratch's weren't a big deal and I offered them to refund me $15-20 and I'd keep it. They did me even better and gave me their cost on it and refunded the difference! Unreal service. I will buy all my grips etc. from them going forward.)
       
      Ok, back to the review!
       
      The putter fit my eye immediately. I have only ever had one other golf club where I just knew I was going to hit it well and that I'd love it at first sight. It was a Cobra knockoff driver I won in the 90's in a closest to the pin contest. This putter was the same way. I just knew I was going to love it and play well with it. I have played ten rounds so far and only six three putts. My first round with it I swooped and won three skins with a twenty foot putt and did it again later in the round with a thirty five foot putt for three more skins (The guys weren't mocking me anymore for having a Tommy Armour putter after that haha)! I do not normally sink many long putts. My longest previous this year wouldn't have been any longer than fifteen feet.
       
      It is really well balanced, the pistol grip is actually very comfortable (I may replace it with something different down the road, we'll see) and I think it looks good. The head cover I can't say the same for, it's pretty ugly and doesn't fit on that well. That's a fairly minor issue, especially considering the price and performance of this putter. 
      On long putts I can easily line it up and it's no different on the short ones. The feel is just right for me, not too firm and not too soft, so they got the insert just right.  I just have so much confidence with this thing that I can't say enough about it. I would have paid five times as much if I knew it was going to make this kind of difference in my game. My putting stats show that I've dropped almost four strokes off my rounds. I was averaging thirty six PPR and now it's down to thirty two I took no lessons and used no training aids. It was all the putter. If someone would have told me a putter would shave three to four strokes off my game I would have laughed at you! 
       
      Bottom line is I love this putter. What a value the guys at Dicks have come up with....they made a world class putter for the $100 range. Thank you MY GOLF SPY, without this site I would never have given this a chance. You saved me spending $400+ on an Evenroll, so thank you guys for that.
       
      Looks – 7/10
      Feel – 9/10
      Alignment – 10/10
      Value – 11/10
       
      Overall – 9/10 – I highly, highly recommend this putter.
       

       





  • Recent Topics

  • Latest from the Blog

  • Happy Birthday Today!

×
×
  • Create New...