Scotty Cameron Coronado first run value

[bclark215]

I am a DIY everything guy. I've refinished several guns with various finishes and have been looking into refinishing a putter. I was in a local pawn shop today looking for any dinged up old scottys. I found a set of Titliest DCI oversize irons with the DCI woods, 1 hybrid, and driver, in an old burton bag. As I dug through I found what I was looking for. A Scotty Cameron Coronado first run of 500. I didn't really need the irons but they would only sell me the entire set, so I purchased the bag, irons, woods, and putter for basically nothing. 

 

The older Coronado wasn't a putter I was very familiar with however so I started to do some digging and have found them selling on ebay for anywhere from <150 to 700+. I was hoping whether someone could help me figure out what this putter in this condition is worth, before I go an potentially mess it up trying to refinish it. 

 

Here are links to some photos. The putter says "SCOTTY CAMERON,  CORONADO, 1ST RUN, 1995/500"  Thanks!

https://imgur.com/uxk1Sce
https://imgur.com/YAmjKqu
https://imgur.com/s3bcU0Q
https://imgur.com/Vmfc7og

[Tres]

I'll give you $300 for it

[RobotDoctor]

Do not refinish the putter.  The value will plummet on the collector's market.  This putter should fetch anywhere between $200-$500 in the condition as is, maybe a little more.  refinishing it will remove the original milling marks and collectors hate that.  The original head cover itself could fetch north of $200 by itself since it is an original head cover.   I would suggest reaching out to collectors on The Cameron Collector to see if anyone is interested. 

 

If you're wanting to game the putter do it as is.  If you refinish it send it to BOS Golf in San Marcos, CA as they refinished this putter originally in a gunned blue finish.  Cameron does not offer the original finish at his Custom Shop.

Edited March 4, 2021 by RobotDoctor