Had both Skechers Twist Fit system and Footjoy BOA. Sketchers system was a bit lacking in the quality department, but I find their shoes more comfortable than most of the other brands. Probably will stick to laces with Sketchers in the future. Footjoy's BOA system is a lot better ( I have this on their Winter Boots) but not as comfortable over a full round so haven't used them as much. Depends on the quality of the BOA system, but I'm 60/40 in favour of laces from my experience