MGS Blog - We Tried it: Footwear Series

[GolfSpy_APH]

Connor at HQ has been rocking it with the footwear reviews and they deserve some added love on the forum. Stay tuned to this thread as we update with all the We Tried It Footwear series Connor puts out. You will be able to find links to the article and maybe some photos which have been posted as well!

Kicking off is the Puma Alphacat Nitro Golf Shoe Review!

https://mygolfspy.com/we-tried-it/puma-alphacat-nitro-golf-shoe-review/

PUMA ALPHACAT NITRO Spikeless Golf Shoes: Marked Improvement

[StrokerAce]

sad to read this part:

Quote

From the top down, the PUMA ALPHACAT NITRO has an extremely narrow and pointed toe. The resulting fit would definitely cause someone with a wider foot than mine pain and discomfort. 

The overall shaping just seems to scrunch the toes rather than let them naturally spread. 

Allowing your foot to naturally spread is critical to comfortable shoes when walking 18 (5+ miles)...

 

[GolfSpy_Connor]

3 minutes ago, StrokerAce said:

sad to read this part:

Allowing your foot to naturally spread is critical to comfortable shoes when walking 18 (5+ miles)...

 

It's something PUMA has a problem with and I'm not sure why they won't fix it. ECCO is a great example of a company that allows plenty of room in the toebox. 

[GolfSpy_APH]

3 minutes ago, StrokerAce said:

sad to read this part:

Allowing your foot to naturally spread is critical to comfortable shoes when walking 18 (5+ miles)...

 

Couldn't agree more. I am have loved my previous Pumas, but they were always the flex versions which offered a ton of space (I dont have wide feet). 

I am still really curious and wanting to try/own the Allbirds shoes he reviewed not too long ago. 

[Fred Mitchell]

Their clothes are the same way for me, same size shorts or shirt as another brand and they are snug.

[Bucky CC]

I bought a pair of last year's Proadapt Alphacat Disc recently and the toe box on those fits me pretty well.  I agree Ecco seems to be the most consistent in this area, but I've had issues with their heel being too firm and causing blisters (especially the G3).

[GolfSpy_APH]

https://mygolfspy.com/buyers-guides/golf-shoes/best-spikeless-golf-shoes-2023/

From a little bit ago, but worth sharing again. 

As a spikeless fan this is where I pay close attention to what I am using and wanting. Would love to hear the memberships input on these and what they use as well!

[Preeway]

I have both the CodeChaos 22 and the Solarmotion from Adidas. Love them both. Found the Solarmotion at a local Adidas outlet store and liked it so much I went back and bought the other pair they had in my size. Best shoes I’ve bought in years. Hands down. Will have to look into the Paynters. Never heard of that brand. 

[IndyBonzo]

I have the ZG21 BOA from Adidas, and have disliked it immensely.  The heel pad wore out immediately.  Spikes are nearly impossible to remove for replacement.  I had to pry them out with a screwdriver because they won't twist out.  No more Adidas for me.  They were so expensive I just kept them until my stubbornness gave way yesterday.

On MGS's recommendation I just picked up some FJ Hyperflex Carbons.  Fingers crossed this is a better experience.  

[Preeway]

13 minutes ago, IndyBonzo said:

On MGS's recommendation I just picked up some FJ Hyperflex Carbons.  Fingers crossed this is a better experience.  

Got a pair of these for my son. He loves them and they are in my short list of next shoes to try. 

[GolfSpy_APH]

https://mygolfspy.com/we-tried-it/cole-haan-originalgrand-golf-shoe-review/

https://mygolfspy.com/we-tried-it/cole-haan-originalgrand-golf-shoe-review/

[StrokerAce]

this brings to mind something that is extremely relative to every person but I'm just curious - how much is "too much" for a golf shoe?

As someone with a painful bunion on their right foot that has had surgery to correct it and now has 2 screws in my big and next to the big toe, I absolutely agree that there is no price for comfort - but at what point do you say - whoa, hang on, that's unreasonable.

[GolfSpy_APH]

https://mygolfspy.com/we-tried-it/the-best-spikeless-shoes-of-2023-have-gone-laceless/

Not my cup of tea at first glance, but maybe if they are comfortable?

@GolfSpy_Connor will be on our community call Thursday and I may have to pry his thoughts on these a little further.

[MattF]

Ugly as a hat full of ear holes.

[GolfSpy_APH]

https://mygolfspy.com/we-tried-it/jordan-adg-4-review/

Now these look clean!

[cnosil]

On 8/20/2023 at 3:44 AM, GolfSpy_APH said:

https://mygolfspy.com/we-tried-it/the-best-spikeless-shoes-of-2023-have-gone-laceless/

Not my cup of tea at first glance, but maybe if they are comfortable?

@GolfSpy_Connor will be on our community call Thursday and I may have to pry his thoughts on these a little further.

Adam made me try these on last night.    I am pretty basic with my typical shoe choice but  I will say that after putting them on they weren’t as bad as I thought they would be.  They do look better on than just looking at them.   Can’t comment on comfort since @GolfSpy_Connor foot is a little larger than mine.   

[GolfSpy_APH]

6 minutes ago, cnosil said:

Adam made me try these on last night.    I am pretty basic with my typical shoe choice but  I will say that after putting them on they weren’t as bad as I thought they would be.  They do look better on than just looking at them.   Can’t comment on comfort since @GolfSpy_Connor foot is a little larger than mine.   

Adam made you? Haha 

It may be more that they are white vs anything else. I don't trust myself to keep them clean long term.

[Josh Parker]

On 8/20/2023 at 2:44 AM, GolfSpy_APH said:

https://mygolfspy.com/we-tried-it/the-best-spikeless-shoes-of-2023-have-gone-laceless/

Not my cup of tea at first glance, but maybe if they are comfortable?

@GolfSpy_Connor will be on our community call Thursday and I may have to pry his thoughts on these a little further.

I wouldn't wear them... It's all about comfort for me.  I have a wide foot so finding good shoes is hard, but I can't say I would even attempt these even in a wide model.

[GolfSpy_APH]

https://mygolfspy.com/we-tried-it/adidas-mc80-golf-shoe-review/

After the call last night I know how much Connor loves these shoes and have very high praise for them!

[GolfSpy_APH]

Always been a fan of Under Armour shoes, whether it was golf or otherwise I have always had success with them.

@GolfSpy Dave has his review on their latest shoe!

https://mygolfspy.com/we-tried-it/under-armour-hovr-drive-wide-golf-shoe-review/

What do you think?

[JStapp]

On 6/14/2023 at 2:31 PM, StrokerAce said:

sad to read this part:

Allowing your foot to naturally spread is critical to comfortable shoes when walking 18 (5+ miles)...

 

You would think walking in golf shoes would be thought number 1 when creating these types of shoes. Golfers walk a ton, and want to be comfortable at all times. I guess, maybe its just aimed at certain people, but that seems counter intuitive to me.  

[JStapp]

On 6/14/2023 at 2:28 PM, GolfSpy_APH said:

Connor at HQ has been rocking it with the footwear reviews and they deserve some added love on the forum. Stay tuned to this thread as we update with all the We Tried It Footwear series Connor puts out. You will be able to find links to the article and maybe some photos which have been posted as well!

Kicking off is the Puma Alphacat Nitro Golf Shoe Review!

https://mygolfspy.com/we-tried-it/puma-alphacat-nitro-golf-shoe-review/

PUMA ALPHACAT NITRO Spikeless Golf Shoes: Marked Improvement

I also strongly recommend and would never go away from Footjoy styles personally. 

[GolfSpy_APH]

Among amateur golfers I have seen Ecco is one of the most common shoes (personal experience). 

Now they have the Biom Tour spiked shoe, check out the full article here: https://mygolfspy.com/news-opinion/first-look/ecco-biom-tour/

[KC Golf]

Adidas cleats. I call them cheap and cheerful. Fit great and last about a year.  My heals usually wear out before the rest of the shoe.  No blisters good traction.

Would love to see if the Adidas cleats are any better or worse in terms of wear than these more expensive brands like FJ and Ecco. At double the price, I am not sure they’d re worth it,  I used to play FJs, but now I am sold on just buying cheaper cleats since they on,y last about a year.  No fashion points needed on the course.

[RTH1]

1 hour ago, KC Golf said:

No fashion points needed in the course.

Agree, just be waterproof and comfortable.

[Dilly22]

Felt inclined to comment on this topic… I’m an RN moving in an NP role and walk/on my feet 12-14 hours most days. My feet are awful and shoes are a struggle for me. That being said I discovered that ASICS actually sells golf shoes. Specifically one of their best sellers (and the style I wear) for a 1:1 transfer from running shoe to golf shoe. It had changed the game for me walking 9-18 and even days riding 18. I had old Nike golf shoes before these that was really taking a toll on my feet as I was walking 3-10 miles on my days off as well as during the week. Would be interesting if anyone had a similar experience with another brand.

[Big moose]

I have tried different brands in the past, I didn't like the Nike or etonic so I tried footjoy and been buying them for years, I wanted to try there boa shoe but it was so hard for me to reach the knob with it being on the heel. So I tried the ASICS boa because the knob is on the side and I really like the way they look and feel, these are my go to shoes almost every time play. 

[GolfSpy_APH]

https://mygolfspy.com/we-tried-it/g-fore-g-112-review/

Now sure exactly what it is about these, but I really like the look of them! 

Read Conner's full review in link above!

[Josh Parker]

Shoes in general for me are always a challenge. I have to have a 4E width and you would be surprised at how few options are out there.  I run alot and when I buy shoes, I typically purchase several pairs because of the lack of wide options.

I actually found my current golf shoes thru Puma.  Spikeless and comfortable to wear. I don't walk my home course but every tee box is elevated and the course and walking to your ball from the cart path get plenty of steps in. 

 

[Shlax]

Interesting thread! Shoes are a very important part of a golfer’s equipment and they often do not have the amount of accessible reviews that clubs, balls, and tech have.

I buy my shoes online 90% of the time (for convenience’s sake and sales) so having access to some intel would be useful to me.

Here are a few notes about shoes that I own that would be useful to anyone planning on getting a pair:

• New Balance Freshfoam Links Pro: My favourite shoes that I own in terms of style. Very comfortable but they are on the larger size and have quite a wide fit. Being white shoes and mostly made from canvas, maintenance is painful, to say the least, and impermeability is nonexistent. Would definitely not recommend for golfers playing mostly early morning rounds with dew or during shoulder seasons. Moreover, they do retain smell more than other shoes…
• Puma Ignite PwrAdapt Caged: Very stable and comfy shoes. I went 0.5 size down per Puma’s recommendations and they were indeed right. Impermeability is not a strongpoint. On the contrary, airflow and moisture wicking features are very solid. Interesting fact: They are heavy! Nothing to cause any discomfort or lack of mobility but it’s just something that strucked me when I first got them. Good all around shoes in my opinion.
• Under Armour Draw Sport: Comfiest shoes that I own and also oldest. Very light, waterproof and durable. Great for quick 9s after work, on a par 3 course and for rounds on a flat course. Semi-unconspicuous golf apparel: I have worn them while runnings some errands on my way back from the course or the range more times than I could count and never got a look. The sole offers plenty of grip despite being "spikeless".
• Nike Air Zoom Victory Tour 2: My latest addition with my main focus placed on waterproofness. Played a very wet and long 5-hour round under a constant drizzle yesterday and my feet were bone dry at the end of the day. Very impressed with the light weight despite being 100% leather shoes. On the other hand, they have a very narrow and tight fit and I don’t usually wear wide fitting shoes… Going 0.5 size up could be an option. Also, you can somewhat feel the cleats when walking on harder surfaces (e.g., greens, asphalt, etc). I wouldn’t recommend these shoes at full retail price, but I got them at 50% off for shoulder seasons which is fine.

Edited September 19, 2023 by Shlax
Typos