Jump to content
Sen

New 2019 Maltby Driving Iron FDI(updated highly requested old HDI)

Recommended Posts

Our Sponsors

I had another range session this morning putting my various long club options through the paces off the deck: ST190 3 wood, ST190 5 wood, 816 H1 21* hybrid, G15 3 iron (20*), KE4 FDI 19*, and TE forged 4i (24*).
1. The G15 3i iron was quickly eliminated as the offset and overall look is so dissimilar to the rest of the set that I can't consider it.
2. I hit the 816 H1 5 times and despite my best efforts something about my swing at the moment and that club is just not resulting in good ball speeds. 
3. The TE forged 4 iron is very consistent, this is a great club for me and gaps in well but is probably not useful for long par 3s or par 5s.
4. I hit the FDI 23 times.  6 were various categories of bad strikes, 2 of them 20+ yards less than median carry, another 2 10+ yards less, and another 2 5+ yards less. The balance of 17 were ok to excellent strikes.  Among the 17 only 1 of them failed to reach 60 foot height.
5. I hit the 5 wood 19 times.  It just does not go as far as I would like it to.  I'm getting about 5 more yards carry out of it than the FDI.  Mishits still get sufficient launch.  I had a similar mishit % and std dev of carry as the FDI.
6. I hit the 3 wood 9 times.  The average shot is 14 yards more carry than the 5 wood. 
Takeaways:
The data says the 3 wood is clearly the best option for me for maximum distance advancement shots (2nd shots par 5s).  The 5 wood gaps reasonably well behind the 3 wood, but is NOT a max advancement club. 
The FDI is useful for the 170 yard par 3 shot I mentioned, shots from 165 off the deck, and shots were the wind is a concern.  It would probably be wise to bend the FDI 1* to 2* weak to try to get it to gap ideally between the 4 iron and 5 wood.  I need more testing with the 816 H1 because I had success last year with that club.
Dave
Thanks for your feedback I had a similar situation I came to the realization in my fitting and looking at game golf data I hit my 5 wood less then once a round and then have a 1i and 4i which only go about 5 yards apart. So my intent with the FDI was to replace the 1 iron (mostly for punch shots) with something slightly longer slightly more stable yet still versitile for those punch shots.
We will see once I get more play but things are looking good so far. Also the few times I have hit it off the tee for a hard dogleg it was a good solid flight.

Using MyGolfSpy mobile app

  • Like 1

Driver:  Ben Hogan GS53
3W:  Callaway Big Bertha Steelhead 2
2i: Maltby KE4 FDI 
4-PW:  Maltby TS-1 - C-Taper 120g 
50º: Maltby TSW

56º:  Cleveland RTX-2 
60º: Maltby Tour Grind MG
Putter:  Odyssey White Hot RX 2-ball

Ball: Snell MTB X
Other: Game Golf Live
Handicap: 5.9  -  Best Score: 73 (1 over) Bryan Park - Players Course, Greensboro NC -2020

2020 MGS Forum Tester - Ben Hogan GS53 Driver

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 hours ago, WalterS said:

thanks for your test results.

 

33 minutes ago, pozzit said:

Thanks for your feedback I had a similar situation I came to the realization in my fitting and looking at game golf data I hit my 5 wood less then once a round and then have a 1i and 4i which only go about 5 yards apart. So my intent with the FDI was to replace the 1 iron (mostly for punch shots) with something slightly longer slightly more stable yet still versitile for those punch shots.
We will see once I get more play but things are looking good so far. Also the few times I have hit it off the tee for a hard dogleg it was a good solid flight.

Using MyGolfSpy mobile app
 

Thank you both, I appreciate it.

There's only so much you can learn from hitting into a net from a mat.  i think it's likely I'm best off really getting the 21* and 25* 816 H1 hybrids sorted out to get better performance from a variety of lies, but I think the FDI has a lot of potential. 

It truly is a rocket launcher for an iron type profile.  I didn't expect it would be sneaking up on 5 wood distance!

Dave

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest Delete
Posted (edited)
On 5/17/2019 at 7:58 AM, bellairemi said:

How is the trajectory of the driving iron versus a 5 iron or 5 hybrid

Delete

Edited by Delete
Delete

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Golf courses in Illinois open on 5/1 and while I like the FDI it did not make the cut.  I'm putting my 21* 816 H1 in the bag instead gapping between the 4 iron and 5 wood.  I think it gives me better versatility and will strictly be used to cover a yardage range rather than tee use.  I'm planning to use 3 wood or 5 wood off the tee on tight/risky par 4s.

I would have been better off buying the 21* FDI instead of the 19*.

Dave

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hey guys, I’m parting ways with my Maltby k4 irons and 2-3-4-5 hybrids email me at benlberryv AT geeee mail if you want them

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


×
×
  • Create New...