Edel SMS and SMS Pro Irons - 2023 Forum Review

[GolfSpy_KFT]

25 minutes ago, GolfSpy BOS said:

Tri-step milled sole.  Supposed to give you the benefits of a narrow sole while playing like a forgiving cavity back irons.

Dude, that sole grind is absolutely awesome. Cannot wait to see how they perform for you. Really curious to hear if you think it'll do what the claim says with extra forgiveness while I would assume allowing for a more workable club.

[srooch2]

40 minutes ago, GolfSpy BOS said:

That shape is nice

 

 

 

 

 

27 minutes ago, GolfSpy BOS said:

[DRLEONARD58]

56 minutes ago, GolfSpy BOS said:

I almost feel a little bad sharing these since most are still waiting on shipping.... but I just have to share these!

I got a nice delivery yesterday and after bringing the box inside I had to run to baseball and then had some work to do last night so I haven't gotten too much time to drool...

But calling these beautiful irons would be a gross understatement.  The full set is even better than I was expecting and everything about the packaging told me this is a premium product.

 

 

 

So much drool! Enjoy! Can't wait to hear about your experience with them!

[Placasse61]

1 hour ago, GolfSpy BOS said:

Tri-step milled sole.  Supposed to give you the benefits of a narrow sole while playing like a forgiving cavity back irons.

great. There are lines there must be a shadow/reflection

[GolfSpy BOS]

54 minutes ago, Jnoble89 said:

Dude, that sole grind is absolutely awesome. Cannot wait to see how they perform for you. Really curious to hear if you think it'll do what the claim says with extra forgiveness while I would assume allowing for a more workable club.

It seems to all make sense.  Higher bounce leading edge to help with that initial contact (which I will certainly put to the test as someone who can get steep on a miss) and then the trail edge is supposed to help get back out of the ground faster with shorter divots.  

The course I'm playing Sunday is known for being, well... soggy.  but it also has some thin and compact patches.  So there's a good chance I'll get a variety of lies, even if I managed to hit all fairways (which I won't).

[ejgaudette]

14 minutes ago, GolfSpy BOS said:

It seems to all make sense.  Higher bounce leading edge to help with that initial contact (which I will certainly put to the test as someone who can get steep on a miss) and then the trail edge is supposed to help get back out of the ground faster with shorter divots.  

The course I'm playing Sunday is known for being, well... soggy.  but it also has some thin and compact patches.  So there's a good chance I'll get a variety of lies, even if I managed to hit all fairways (which I won't).

Come on we need the butter knife view, you got the 3 iron right?

[GolfSpy BOS]

2 minutes ago, ejgaudette said:

Come on we need the butter knife view, you got the 3 iron right?

I thought I did, but I must have just put 4-PW... either that or it's on back order... or someone mistakenly put it in the silverwear drawer already.  

[GolfSpy_KFT]

24 minutes ago, GolfSpy BOS said:

It seems to all make sense.  Higher bounce leading edge to help with that initial contact (which I will certainly put to the test as someone who can get steep on a miss) and then the trail edge is supposed to help get back out of the ground faster with shorter divots.  

The course I'm playing Sunday is known for being, well... soggy.  but it also has some thin and compact patches.  So there's a good chance I'll get a variety of lies, even if I managed to hit all fairways (which I won't).

Can’t wait to hear how they play!

[tdroma98]

What a good looking club @GolfSpy BOS!  The 8 iron looks like a cross between the old Ben Hogan Apex Edge & a PXG iron.  Nice!

 

 

[DiscipleofPenick]

2 hours ago, GolfSpy BOS said:

I almost feel a little bad sharing these since most are still waiting on shipping.... but I just have to share these!

I got a nice delivery yesterday and after bringing the box inside I had to run to baseball and then had some work to do last night so I haven't gotten too much time to drool...

But calling these beautiful irons would be a gross understatement.  The full set is even better than I was expecting and everything about the packaging told me this is a premium product.

 

 

 

hot damn I say! Those are gorgeous!!!!

[RollingGreens]

Love the look, the weighting on the back combined the the colored ferrules are top notch quality!

[ChitownM2]

8 hours ago, srooch2 said:

Did any testers go get fit?

A few of us did.  I went to Golftec not sure about the others.  @GolfSpy BOS may have gotten fit at an actual Edel location but I'm not positive.

[Triple_Putt]

16 minutes ago, ChitownM2 said:

A few of us did.  I went to Golftec not sure about the others.  @GolfSpy BOS may have gotten fit at an actual Edel location but I'm not positive.

I went to my local Club Champion for my fitting

[GolfSpy BOS]

1 hour ago, ChitownM2 said:

A few of us did.  I went to Golftec not sure about the others.  @GolfSpy BOS may have gotten fit at an actual Edel location but I'm not positive.

Mine was with a local fitter that I’ve been got with before. They are an Edel authorized dealer and I think we’re with them early on which is kind of cool. 

[ChitownM2]

Just have a quick update for tonight.  I ended up getting to the range for a quick session last Wednesday and I was very happy with how it went.  The clubs feel solid at impact and what my eyes were telling me is that the ball flight is a bit higher than my gamers, which is something that would be beneficial for me since I tend to come in steep with a low launch angle.  I brought my Mevo with me and plan to review the data later to compare and do some direct head to head comparisons to make sure I'm putting the same swing on the ball with each set.  Overall I was a bit inconsistent as it was only my second time at the range this year and I'm definitely not in mid-season form yet.  

That inconsistency carried over into my round on Friday but the issue was all with my driver and woods.  The irons performed well for the first round out, distance seemed the same or better as my Z585s but it was also tough to get a read on things as it was extremely windy and had to be factored in continuously.  Going to see if I can get back out again this week & weekend but no guarantees with a soccer tournament occupying my Friday, Saturday & Sunday along with Mother's Day.

[ejgaudette]

6 hours ago, ChitownM2 said:

Just have a quick update for tonight.  I ended up getting to the range for a quick session last Wednesday and I was very happy with how it went.  The clubs feel solid at impact and what my eyes were telling me is that the ball flight is a bit higher than my gamers, which is something that would be beneficial for me since I tend to come in steep with a low launch angle.  I brought my Mevo with me and plan to review the data later to compare and do some direct head to head comparisons to make sure I'm putting the same swing on the ball with each set.  Overall I was a bit inconsistent as it was only my second time at the range this year and I'm definitely not in mid-season form yet.  

That inconsistency carried over into my round on Friday but the issue was all with my driver and woods.  The irons performed well for the first round out, distance seemed the same or better as my Z585s but it was also tough to get a read on things as it was extremely windy and had to be factored in continuously.  Going to see if I can get back out again this week & weekend but no guarantees with a soccer tournament occupying my Friday, Saturday & Sunday along with Mother's Day.

Glad to hear things are going well. Given that you were playing in the wind, how did they perform there. Was the higher ball flight something you had to adjust to? Did the ball seem to hold up through the wind?

[ChitownM2]

16 hours ago, ejgaudette said:

Glad to hear things are going well. Given that you were playing in the wind, how did they perform there. Was the higher ball flight something you had to adjust to? Did the ball seem to hold up through the wind?

So I noticed the higher ball flight first at the range where it was pretty calm.  I observed the same flight while out on the course while playing in the wind also but I didn't have any issues with the ball ballooning on shots into the wind.  It cut through pretty well so really the only difference was a better descent angle.  It's something I will definitely be paying attention to and will try to get some data on going forward.  

There is a good chance that part of the higher flight is due to the weaker lofts on the longer irons compared to my gamers.  Again I'll have to hit them back to back and try to get some data to confirm over the next few weeks.

[ejgaudette]

7 hours ago, ChitownM2 said:

So I noticed the higher ball flight first at the range where it was pretty calm.  I observed the same flight while out on the course while playing in the wind also but I didn't have any issues with the ball ballooning on shots into the wind.  It cut through pretty well so really the only difference was a better descent angle.  It's something I will definitely be paying attention to and will try to get some data on going forward.  

There is a good chance that part of the higher flight is due to the weaker lofts on the longer irons compared to my gamers.  Again I'll have to hit them back to back and try to get some data to confirm over the next few weeks.

Yes the lofts are quite weak in the long irons bu modern standards, 5 iron is at 26 so yes should go more like many peoples 6 iron height wise. Look forward to hearing more.

[edingc]

On 5/4/2023 at 10:15 AM, GolfSpy BOS said:

Tri-step milled sole.  Supposed to give you the benefits of a narrow sole while playing like a forgiving cavity back irons.

Gorgeous. Similar to the Srixon or Hogan sole, I assume. I probably would get along well with these. 

Love the milling. Still my favorite part of the SMS wedges.

[Javs]

1 hour ago, edingc said:

Gorgeous. Similar to the Srixon or Hogan sole, I assume. I probably would get along well with these. 

Love the milling. Still my favorite part of the SMS wedges.

I love the looks of the sole!

[ejgaudette]

1 hour ago, edingc said:

Gorgeous. Similar to the Srixon or Hogan sole, I assume. I probably would get along well with these. 

Love the milling. Still my favorite part of the SMS wedges.

 

19 minutes ago, Javs said:

I love the looks of the sole!

I am really interesting to see how this performs in the turf. Not really sure what to expect but time will tell

[GolfSpy BOS]

Just as an update to those following this thread and wondering why there aren't more photos being posted... 

There was a grip that went out of stock that three testers had selected,  we've updated orders and should have the rest of the testers clubs in their hands next week.  Then this thread will really get going!

 

 

[Invader Zim 315]

Crazy how HOT the MGS testing forum has been lately, and despite being surrounded by Paradym irons, Takomo, etc.  this has been my favorite iron test to follow so far.

These pictures are insane and these irons are down right delicious.  Can't wait to keep seeing how they perform on course for you all.  Great stuff all cant wait to keep hearing more

[Javs]

1 hour ago, Invader Zim 315 said:

Crazy how HOT the MGS testing forum has been lately, and despite being surrounded by Paradym irons, Takomo, etc.  this has been my favorite iron test to follow so far.

These pictures are insane and these irons are down right delicious.  Can't wait to keep seeing how they perform on course for you all.  Great stuff all cant wait to keep hearing more

Come on Invader get on the Paradym bus. Just kidding!

[ejgaudette]

On 5/12/2023 at 2:14 PM, Invader Zim 315 said:

Crazy how HOT the MGS testing forum has been lately, and despite being surrounded by Paradym irons, Takomo, etc.  this has been my favorite iron test to follow so far.

These pictures are insane and these irons are down right delicious.  Can't wait to keep seeing how they perform on course for you all.  Great stuff all cant wait to keep hearing more

Glad you are enjoying but I hope there will be more coming soon with the rest of the orders hopefully arriving soon!

[GolfSpy AFG]

Well I just went from six to midnight…

[GolfSpy_KFT]

12 minutes ago, Getoffmylawn said:

Well I just went from six to midnight…

Heck yes, @Getoffmylawn! Can't wait to see the unboxing when those sticks arrive!

[GolfSpy BOS]

Great news Hayes!  Was beginning to think you we're just scared to play me in NC! 

[GolfSpy AFG]

1 minute ago, GolfSpy BOS said:

Great news Hayes!  Was beginning to think you we're just scared to play me in NC! 

[GolfSpy_SHARK]

23 minutes ago, Getoffmylawn said:

Well I just went from six to midnight…

Better charge that battery so you can continuously track the updates!